ESMA report highlights liquidity concerns for Alternative Investment Funds
The European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA), the EU
securities regulator, today publishes its third annual statistical
report on the Alternative Investment Fund (AIF) sector. The report has
found that the sector increased by 15% in 2019 to EUR 6. 8trn in net
assets from EUR 5. 9trn in 2018.
The main risks faced by the
sector relate to a mismatch between the potential liquidity of the
assets, and the redemption timeframe offered to investors. This is
particularly the case for real estate funds and funds of funds. For
hedge funds, the issue of leverage is key at more than 900%, in a
sector valued at EUR 354bn in net asset value (NAV), including EUR
269bn for hedge funds with UK AIFMs.
The AIF sector was
heavily impacted by the COVID-19 related market stress during the
first quarter of 2020, and while outside the reporting period, a
snapshot of the main event is included in the report.
Main
findings: The size of the EU AIF universe continued to expand to reach
EUR 6. 8tn in NAV at the end of 2019, a 15% increase from 5. 9trn in
2018. The growth of the EU AIF market results from the launch of new
AIFs in 2019 and positive valuation effects; Funds of Funds (FoFs)
account for 15% of the NAV of EU AIFs, at around EUR 1tn (+22%
compared with EUR 841bn in 2018). At the very short end, investors can
redeem 39% of the NAV within one day, whereas only 29% of assets could
be liquidated within this time frame. If large redemptions were to
occur, AIFs would face challenges due to this liquidity mismatch;
Real Estate Funds account for 12% of the NAV of AIFs, at EUR 802bn.
They continued to grow, albeit at a more moderate pace (+9% in 2019
after +35% in 2018). Compared with 2018, the proportion of retail
investors was stable (21%) but remains high compared with other AIF
categories. RE funds are exposed mostly to illiquid physical assets
which take time to sell, so liquidity risk in RE funds remains a
concern; The size of the EU Hedge Fund sector remained stable in 2019
at EUR 354bn, or 5% of all AIFs. However, when measured by gross
exposures, HFs account for 62% of AIFs since they rely heavily on
derivatives. Leverage is very high at more than 900% after
adjustments, and particularly so for some strategies highly reliant on
derivatives; Private Equity Funds account for 7% of the NAV of all
AIFs, or EUR 456bn, and experienced the largest growth in 2019 (+28%
compared with xxx in 2018). They follow a range of strategies and are
almost exclusively sold to professional investors; Other AIFs account
for 60% of the NAV of EU AIFs, at around EUR 4tn (+15% compared with
xxx in 2018). The category covers a range of strategies, with fixed
income and equity strategies accounting for 68% of the NAV and an
additional residual category amounting to 29%. Other AIFs are mainly
sold to professional investors, although there is a significant retail
investor presence; and EU Member States can allow non-EU asset
managers to market alternative funds at national level under the
National Private Placement Regime (NPPR), even though such funds
cannot subsequently be passported in to other Members States. The
market for such non-EU funds is comparatively large: The NAV of non-EU
AIFs marketed under NPPRs’ rules amounts to EUR 2. 1tn, i. e. more
than one-fifth of the AIF market. NPPR fund marketing is concentrated
in a small number of Member States, and 98% of investors are
professional investors.
ESMA will continue to report annually
on its analysis.